← Market reports

September 2023

Nantucket closed sales for September 2023, compared with September 2022 and the prior twelve months.

Reporting period · September 1, 2023–September 30, 2023Reconstructed reportBy Stephen Maury · Principal BrokerPublished 2026-11-22

The month at a glance

All property types · Compared with September 2022

Closed sales
34
−22.7% from 44
Dollar volume
$198.67M
+2.2% from $194.38M
Median sale price
$3.70M
+23.8% from $2.99M
The median is the middle sale price in the ordered set. It describes the mix sold, not individual property appreciation.

Recorded LINK MLS closings, including homes, land, and commercial property.

Year to date

January through September · All property types

Year to date through September 30, 2023
Measure20232022Change
Closed sales215302−28.8%
Dollar volume$818.91M$1.073B−23.7%
Median sale price$2,600,000$2,384,000+9.1%

The longer view

Single months

Rolling 12 months

Days on market is the MLS-reported field, not elapsed time from listing to closing. Final asking price is the last list price before the sale. Original asking price is the first recorded list price.

Rolling 12-month comparisons
MeasureOct 2022–Sep 2023Oct 2021–Sep 2022Change
Closed sales354528−33.0%
Dollar volume$1.380B$1.934B−28.7%
Median sale price$2,575,000$2,489,500+3.4%
Median days on market42.5 n = 25837 n = 381—
Median sale / final asking price98.8% n = 354100.0% n = 528—
Median sale / original asking price97.2% n = 31898.4% n = 469—

Price and time on market

Time on market and asking price
MeasureSeptember 2023September 2022
Median days on market38.5 n = 3029 n = 33
Median sale / final asking price97.4% n = 3497.9% n = 44
Median sale / original asking price96.2% n = 3397.7% n = 42

n = sales with the data. Missing values are excluded only from the affected measure.

Sales by segment

By property type

September 2023 and September 2022 · closed sales by property type
Property typeSeptember 2023September 2022
SalesVolumeMedian priceSalesVolumeMedian price
Single-family homes27$185,477,500$4,400,00030$157,511,772$3,525,000
Condominiums — small sample; fewer than five sales in at least one displayed period3$5,599,000$1,000,0000$0Not available
Land — small sample; fewer than five sales in at least one displayed period1$1,950,000$1,950,0009$28,896,000$1,780,000
Commercial — small sample; fewer than five sales in at least one displayed period2$3,150,000$1,575,0001$1,600,000$1,600,000
Multifamily — small sample; fewer than five sales in at least one displayed period0$0Not available2$3,550,000$1,775,000
Co-ops — small sample; fewer than five sales in at least one displayed period1$2,495,000$2,495,0001$2,050,000$2,050,000
Unclassified — small sample; fewer than five sales in at least one displayed period0$0Not available1$775,000$775,000

By price band

September 2023 · closed-sale prices by band
Closing priceSalesVolumeShare of volume
Under $2M6$7,824,0003.9%
$2M–under $5M16$53,315,00026.8%
$5M–under $10M8$55,195,00027.8%
$10M+ — small sample; fewer than five sales in this displayed period4$82,337,50041.4%

† Small sample: fewer than five sales in at least one displayed period.

Price-band shares may total slightly above or below 100% because each displayed share is rounded to one decimal place.

Reading September’s results

Closed sales fell; median price rose

Single-family homes made up 27 of September’s 34 closings, down from 30 in September 2022, and their median price rose from $3.525 million to $4.4 million (+24.8%). All other property types went from 14 sales to 7 sales. 6 closings, 3.9% of dollar volume, were under $2 million. The single-family and all-property medians are reported separately, so a shift in the all-property median is not attributed only to land or commercial sales. These figures do not show why; the properties sold may differ in size, location, or condition from those sold a year earlier.

Rolling 12-month context

The 12 months ending September 30, 2023 recorded 354 sales and $1.380 billion in volume, compared with 528 sales and $1.934 billion in the 12 months ending September 30, 2022. The median sale price rose from $2.49 million to $2.575 million (+3.4%).

Days on market and asking-price gaps

Median days on market rose from 29 days across 33 sales in September 2022 to 38.5 days across 30 sales in September 2023. Median sale-to-final asking price fell from 97.9% to 97.4%; median sale-to-original asking price fell from 97.7% to 96.2%. Over the trailing 12 months, median days on market rose from 37 days across 381 sales in the 12 months ending September 30, 2022 to 42.5 days across 258 sales in the 12 months ending September 30, 2023.

4 sales at $10 million or more made up 41.4% of volume

Single-family homes accounted for 27 of the month’s 34 sales and $185.478 million of its volume. 4 transactions at $10 million or more contributed $82.338 million. Condominiums, Land, Commercial, and Co-ops each had fewer than five sales and should be read as individual activity, not reliable segment trends.

What this means for owners

Owners considering a sale

September’s median sale-to-final asking-price ratio fell from 97.9% to 97.4%, and its median sale-to-original asking-price ratio fell from 97.7% to 96.2%. The monthly and rolling-period days-on-market results provide context for a sale timetable, but do not establish how long a particular property would take to sell.

Owners holding their property

September’s all-property median sale price rose from $2.988 million to $3.7 million (+23.8%); it compares different properties sold in different months and does not measure the change in value of an individual property. The trailing-12-month median rose from $2.49 million to $2.575 million (+3.4%). A comparison with recent sales of similar properties is what indicates the value of a specific home.

Condominiums, Land, Commercial, and Co-op owners

With fewer than five closings in each of these categories, individual comparables and property characteristics carry more weight than the monthly category medians.

Stephen Maury
Principal Broker

Sources & method

Data provided courtesy of Congdon & Coleman Real Estate via LINK MLS. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Scope
Nantucket MLS records classified as closed, dated September 1, 2023–September 30, 2023, with a positive recorded sale price. All property types are included. This is an MLS closed-sale series, not a census of all deeds or a screened arm’s-length transaction index.
Historical reconstruction
Prepared from historical closing records retrieved November 21, 2026. Later corrections may be reflected in those records; this is not a preserved copy of the database as it stood in September 2023. No transactions closing after September 30, 2023 enter this report’s calculations.
Comparisons
Monthly comparisons use September 2022. Trailing periods are October 1, 2022–September 30, 2023 and October 1, 2021–September 30, 2022.
Calculations
Volume is the sum of closing prices; the median is the middle observation, averaging the middle pair for an even sample. Sale-to-list measures are medians of individual sale-price / asking-price ratios, not ratios of aggregate prices. Changes are relative percentages, with no percentage reported against a zero denominator.
Record quality
Rolling-period figures use the same 882 closed-sale records (October 1, 2021–September 30, 2023). 2915 additional records were excluded. Records are deduplicated by MLS listing identity, never by parcel alone: separate units or properties can share a parcel. Each row is a recorded MLS closing, not necessarily a distinct deed. Samples below five are identified beside the affected results.
Unavailable historical measures
Month-end active inventory, new contracts signed, and months of supply are not reported. A complete contemporaneous status history has not been verified for September 2023; present-day inventory cannot stand in for it.

Congdon & Coleman Real Estate, Massachusetts Licensed Real Estate Broker #422678.

← Market reports