The Best Grocery Stores in Nantucket

Finding the right food store is mandatory for a great stay in Nantucket. Besides the attractions like the beaches, you need good food, and Nantucket is never short of the right supplies.

Even though Nantucket’s most renowned grocery store remains the Mid-Island Stop & Shop, there are several other worthwhile grocery stores where you can get fresh organic produce.

Here are some of the best options.

Bartlett’s Farm

• Location: 33 Bartlett Farm Rd, Nantucket, MA 02554, US
• Contact: 508-228-9403
• Website: bartlettsfarm.com

Having been operating since the 1800s, Bartlet’s farm is one of Nantucket’s oldest and most iconic grocery stores. The farm is a multi-faceted family venture with over 100 acres for producing farm products. 30 acres of the land is used to produce certified organic groceries with multiple greenhouses for greens, herbs, and tomatoes.

Besides veggies, the farm offers a wide range of freshly prepared foods for takeaway. You can choose from sandwiches, salads, soups, desserts, and dinner specials. There are also drinks like roasted coffee, espresso drinks, wine, and craft beers.

Stop & Shop Mid Island

• Location: 31 Sparks Ave, Nantucket, MA 02554, US
• Contact:508-228-2178
• Website: stores.stopandshop.com/ma/nantucket

If you are looking for fresh and healthy foods at great value in Nantucket, then Stop & Shop Mid Island is an ideal place for you. Operational for over 100 years, the grocery store opened its doors in Nantucket in 2014. It offers a wide assortment of fresh produce like seafood, meats, and fresh produce. You can also explore other specialty supplies like flowers, beach supplies, and an olive bar.

The grocery store is customer-focused with various community-focused initiatives like fighting hunger and investing in cancer research initiatives.

You can conveniently shop from the store either online or by physically visiting. For regular shoppers, consider the loyalty program, where you earn points every time you shop.

Another Stop & Shop store at 9 Salem Street is equally ideal for your fresh produce shopping.

Nantucket Meat & Fish Market

• Location: 21 Old South Rd, Nantucket, MA 02554, US
• Contact: 774-333-5176
• Website: nantucketmeatandfish.com

Nantucket Meat & Fish market is a leading family-owned and operated business focusing on a friendly and personal shopping experience. As a gourmet food shop, the store provides exceptional fresh seafood, bagel bakery, prime meat, sushi, and groceries.

The Nantucket Meat & Fish also offers special breakfast and other pre-made food options. Check out its steak tips.

Moors End Farm

• Location: 40 Polpis Rd, Nantucket, MA 02554, US
• Contact: 508-228-2674
• Website: moorsendfarm.com

Moors End Farm is excellent if you are looking for fresh farm produce, healthy plants, and beautiful flowers. Founded in the mid-1970s as a self-serve farm stand, the grocery store has become a major fresh supply outlet in Nantucket. It has a constant supply of annuals and small and perennial products available on the land.

Thanks to its serene surroundings, the store is an ideal place to tour while on a shopping spree. It’s easily accessible, and you can either bike or use a vehicle. You will always find the perfect Christmas tree at the store for the festive season and flower pots in the summer.

Pumpkin Pond Farm

• Location: 25 Millbrook Rd, Nantucket, MA 02554, US
• Contact: 508-332-4750
• Website: pumpkinpondfarm

The Pumpkin Pond Farm is a certified organic farm with an Eden-like oasis of color and flavor. It has a variety of fresh produce of vegetables and greens, trees, shrubs, and perennials. You can also find your supply of rare antique garden ephemera.

The grocery store is all about sustainability and good soil science. It takes pride in being the island’s leading nutrient-rich-organic food supply point. It buys all its seeds and heirlooms only from certified organic suppliers.

The farm is the leading supplier of most Nantucket restaurants with organic farm products. It also takes part in the popular Nantucket Garden Festival that occurs mid-year.

Sayle’s Seafood

• Location: 99 Washington St Ext, Nantucket, MA 02554, US
• Contact: 508-228-4599
• Website: saylesseafood.com

While in Nantucket, you should have a taste of seafood, and no place works best for you than Sayle’s Seafood. It is a full fish market near the Great Harbour Yacht Club by the Harbour and is easily accessible from the town.

The store has many seafood options, from lobsters to mussels and other fish. They also have a variety of special dinner supplies, sandwiches, and sides to choose from.

The store is open year-round and allows for convenient online ordering.

167 Raw

• Location: 167 Hummock Pond Rd, Nantucket, MA 02554, US
• Contact: 508-228-2871
• Website: 167raw.com/nantucket

Founded in 1978, 167 Raw is a leading fresh fish and other supplies store in Nantucket. The store has grown over the years to become the go-to place for prime meats, fine cheese, a special collection of wine and beer, and other gourmet items.

The 167 Raw food truck, launched in 2015, provides a cool spot for getting your fine seafood and meats on the go. You also can hire their catering services to bring fresh seafood delicacies to private parties and meetups.

The store has won awards and accolades due to its amazing chain of fresh supplies in Nantucket. They are also known to have the best key lime pie on the island.

Pip & Anchor

• Location: 14 Amelia Dr, Nantucket, MA 02554, US
• Contact: 508-413-9940
• Website: pipandanchor.com

Unlike any other grocery store in Nantucket, Pips & Anchor supports the local community. It looks to build a strong community by supporting the local producers to make and grow things they love while the consumers get healthy supplies. This provides for a healthy population and a thriving local economy.

Due to its focus on local production, Pips & Anchor tends to have seasonal supplies and can sometimes close for the year. When open, it offers a wide range of fresh supplies of bakery, dairy, pantry, and farm products.

Bottom Line

Nantucket is a haven of grocery stores. Whether you are looking for local produce, seafood, meat, or other supplies, there’s always a store for you. The stores are strategically placed, so you don’t have to move around for long before finding the right one.

Besides food supplies, most grocery stores have invested in ambiance and accessibility. They have become an attraction with great views to complement your Nantucket tour.